links for 2007-09-15

3 Responses

  1. Homeopathy addresses so much more than physical manifestations of illness. Therefore saying things like “where mechanisms are suggested, they frequently violate our basic understanding of the natural world” is just silly. As if “our basic understanding” of anything is the only true way, and won’t ever change. These guys ever hear of string theory?

    However, I’m not saying that the methods used by Homeopathy were sound according to the prevailing scientific method. If no current scientific process can measure the actual activity or process behind homeopathy, then they can still measure outcomes. Such experiments have been done on anthroposophical medicines in Europe, which are partially based on homeopathy.

  2. I’m neutral about the issue, though I have to say that the Ars Technica people really gave the evidence presented a fairly thorough kicking! Though, I’m about as suspicious of positivist narratives in general as it’s possible to be without attempting to walk through walls some hegemonic discourse has constructed as “solid”.

  3. i checked out the links these are really good !

Leave a Reply